Should You Hire or Outsource? Tax and Cash Flow Considerations for Growing SMEs

As your business grows, you eventually need more hands. But should you hire staff or outsource work to contractors or agencies?

Both options have tax, cash flow, and operational implications—especially for SMEs in Rugby and Warwickshire.

Hiring: Pros and Cons

✔ Benefits of hiring:

• Consistent availability
• Stronger company culture
• Skills embedded in‑house
• Easier long‑term planning

✘ Downsides:

• Employer National Insurance (15%+)
• Pension contributions (3% minimum)
• Holiday and sick pay obligations
• HR admin and payroll costs

Hiring gives stability—but it’s more expensive and rigid.

Outsourcing: Pros and Cons

✔ Benefits:

• Lower long-term cost
• No employer NI, pension, HR or holiday pay
• “Pay as you go” flexibility
• Access to specialist skills

✘ Downsides:

• Less control
• Potentially higher hourly rates
• Less loyalty or availability
• Risk of over-dependence on contractors

Outsourcing boosts efficiency but can become costly if overused.

Tax & Cash Flow Considerations

1. Employment Taxes

Hiring triggers:

• Employer NI
• Workplace pension contributions
• Apprenticeship levy (for larger employers)

Outsourcing avoids these completely.

2. IR35 Risk

If outsourcing resembles employment, HMRC may reclassify the contractor—leading to penalties.

3. Cash Flow Predictability

• Staff = predictable monthly costs
• Outsourcing = more variable, but easier to scale

4. Corporation Tax Impact

Employment costs are deductible, reducing Corporation Tax.

Hybrid Models Are Growing

Many SMEs are blending the two:

• Core team hired
• Specialist tasks outsourced
• Seasonal tasks handled by freelancers

This keeps costs flexible while retaining quality.

Redwood Accountants Can Help You Decide

We review your:

✔ Profit margins
✔ Cash flow
✔ Hiring affordability
✔ Tax implications
✔ Long‑term growth plans

and recommend the most financially sound route.

Final Thoughts

Hiring and outsourcing both have their place. The right choice depends on your goals, cash flow, and team structure.
Let Redwood Accountants help you create a staffing strategy that supports sustainable growth.

‍